|
|
It was a little over 10
years ago that the Ice Curtain that hung between Alaska's west coast
and the Russian Far East began to thaw. With its melting, a warm
blast of friendship swept across Alaska, infecting many with an
irrepressible case of Russian Fever. The once impossible became an
everyday event as delegations from towns across Alaska were visited
and hosted their Soviet counterparts.
Since that brief time
of mutual wonder and elation, the collapse of the Soviet Union has
raised logistical, financial and political barriers between our two
countries that are almost as effective as the Iron Curtain had been.
And as the number of exchanges decreases, information filtering in
about the rising humanitarian crisis in our neighboring region
increases.
I participated in some of the earliest expeditions
to the Chukotka Region Alaska's nearest neighbor to the west and
traveled the coastline by dog sled and umiaq. I had not returned
since 1993 and was feeling the weight of an unpaid debt for the
incredible kindness and generosity shown me by the Eskimo, Chukchi
and Russian people living up and down the nearby coast. I wanted to
see old friends and to learn what changes had taken place since
those early days of renewed contact.
Grants from the National
Park Service and the Alaska Humanities Forum, to survey people's
perspectives on the re-opening of the border, allowed me to return
for six weeks this past spring. With a translator, I traveled by
iron tank and dog sled to many of the region's villages to see and
hear about the differences that a decade had wrought.
The
realities of capitalism hit swift and hard in Chukotna. Under the
Soviet system, living and working in the Russian Far East was
considered a ``hardship tour.'' The greater the distance from
Moscow, the higher the salary, the longer the vacation and the
better supplied the stores_similar to the treatment of workers at
Alaska's Prudhoe Bay during the pipeline boom. That equation has
reversed 180 degrees in the last 10 years, and the once well
supported villages must fend for themselves. They are now subject to
laws of a free-market economy, but Russia's version of capitalism
doesn't offer the safeguards of democracy, ``rule of law,'' or the
safety net of government assistance that we take for granted in
America.
At an October Park Service Beringia conference in
Anchorage, I learned from Russian friends that the situation has not
improved with the passage of a brief, stormy summer of poor hunting
and no fish. People are scared as the inevitable dark and cold of
winter begin to close in.
When the ice curtain first lifted
on Provideniya, it revealed an active seaport of 10,000 people
perched on a mountainside deep within a fjord-like bay, its
waterfront dominated by huge cranes that serviced supply ships
plying the northern shipping route. The looming concrete apartment
buildings startled those of us accustomed to the wood frame and
shiplap homes of Nome, but we thought with a little paint
Provideniya could become a welcoming tourist destination and an
active Alaska business partner.
Today many of those buildings
stand abandoned, their central heating and water systems broken as
Provideniya's infrastructure crumbles. Without their lace curtains
or windows you peer into the empty coffins of people's former lives.
Some people continue to live in unheated buildings, keeping one or
two rooms warm with electric heaters when there is electricity. My
friend, Luda, checked daily for the comforting plume of sooty smoke
from the town's coal-fired generator that assured there would be
electricity for another day. At the same time, some buildings
continue to operate normally, with residents living in relative
comfort.
The once large, state-run stores have been replaced
with smaller state stores and small, private shops tucked away down
unmarked stairs or in the back of an obscure building. They sell
food flown in from Moscow and Kamchatka, at prices that at first
don't seem too unreasonable to Alaskans_one quart of cooking oil,
$2.40; one pound salami, $2.90; one pound onions, $1.08; one pound
apples, $1.25; five pounds flour, 1.20, a small jar of instant
coffee, $3.13_until you consider that wages range from approximately
600-6,000 rubles ($20- $200) per month, if salaries are received at
all.
Provideniya's population is now down to 3,000 as many
non-natives return to their hometowns in warmer parts of Russia.
There they face the difficulty of finding work, but can at least
subsist on home-grown potatoes, carrots and cabbage. Some are happy
to leave the north, while others are dismayed at having to leave the
land and friends they love. The cost of a one-way ticket is about
six month's salary, so there is little hope of ever
returning.
But there is something about the Russian character
that thrives in hard times. Women still dress in long, beautifully
tailored coats and fox or sable hats as they delicately pick their
way through Provideniya's snowdrifts and mud holes. Friends gather
nightly in the collection of bars and restaurants, where glasses of
vodka are raised in toasts, and people dance into the morning. To
enter someone's home still means to gather close around the kitchen
table.
Under the Soviet system, marine mammal hunters, fur
trappers, reindeer herders, ivory carvers, skin sewers, even dancers
and drummers worked for the state. They were paid a good salary, but
all the products of their labor including the seal, whale and walrus
belonged to the government. People often told me that prior to the
opening of the border they believed they lived very well. But
discovering the selection of fresh produce and consumer goods
available on the other side of the ice curtain, and the collections
of privately owned trucks, four-wheelers, snowmachines, boats,
motors and guns, left people stunned and reconsidering their
standard of living. Yet today that former standard of living is
looked on wistfully as a time of abundance and
comfort.
During my visit I saw basic foodstuffs in most of
the village stores, but at prices few could afford. Irina, a teacher
in Uelen, explained, ``The children look at food in the store as
things in a museum. They can see it but they cannot touch it.''
Friends recently told me that what little European food there was in
the spring is now entirely gone.
A year ago the fuel ship
failed to deliver diesel fuel to Yanrakinot and Sireniki, leaving
both villages to struggle through last winter without electricity
and little heat. Televisions, radios and telephones sat dark and
silent while homes were lit with candles, and whale and seal oil
lamps. The Yanrakinot school could only operate during the brief
daylight hours the change of classes signaled by the ringing of a
handbell instead of the familiar electric buzzer. Families doubled
and tripled up in homes with a stove that could burn scavenged coal
or wood from demolished buildings. One woman in Sireniki described
how they'd built a tent over the living couch where everyone slept
together for warmth.
Recent reports are that all the villages
have received shipments of coal and diesel for the upcoming winter,
but Provideniya and Lavrentia are still waiting and watching
worriedly as their bays begin to freeze up.
Most retirees
receive pension money, but it is often a very small amount. Mothers
also receive small amounts of ``children's compensation'' money, but
with no regularity. The ones with the most reliable incomes are the
lucky few who work as doctors, teachers or for the local
administration, and even they have not been paid for the past four
months. Some workers receive only a small amount of food in trade.
Many have not received any money since 1993 or 1994.
Many
children are facing another winter without adequate winter clothes.
Mittens, hats, boots and jackets are often not available in the
villages, and when they are it is at a price most cannot afford. In
Yanrakinot I saw kids using their parents' oversized boots and was
told that in some families the children have to share the same
outdoor clothing and can only play outside one at a time.
The
schools, even in the larger hub cities of Provideniya and Lavrentia,
struggle with shortages of the most basic items; pencils, pens,
paper. In Uelen, Irina lamented, ``I can teach biology without any
supplies, but how do I teach mathematics without paper and
pencils?''
In Sireniki I was shown where the schools
bathrooms had collapsed, forcing students and teachers to run home,
go outside even in the winter storms, or wet their pants. Disgusted,
the school director told me, ``The communist system was bad, but
this is worse!' Dependence on subsistence.
People are now
entirely dependent on the hunters to provide food but guns and
ammunition are not available, and there is no gasoline to run the
boat motors. In the village of Inchoun this summer the men were once
again rowing and paddling skin boats in pursuit of seals and walrus.
Summer storms piled up unusual amounts of ice along north coast
beaches, often keeping the boats from launching.
Under the
Soviet system, whales were caught by large processing ships and
towed to the villages where the local people butchered them. But the
ships never returned after 1992, leaving the villages without a
critical food source. With guidance from their elders and support
and training from Alaska's North Slope Borough, hunters have
re-learned how to hunt whales from small boats.
Ten years ago
the reindeer herds were large and healthy. The Chukchi herders, who
lived nine months of the year on the tundra in their skin-covered
yarangas, were well paid and comfortable. The herds are now nearly
gone. The reindeer have been eaten for food or traded for other
needed goods. There is no longer vaccine available and little
ammunition for the herders to protect their animals from the
increasing number of wolves. People have lost not only their source
of income and food, but also their traditional lifestyle that holds
reindeer at its center.
In an effort to help people feed
themselves, the grassroots organization, Alaskan Friends of
Chukotka, has sent more than 160 salmon nets to Chukotka villages.
And, apparently, this past summer's disastrous chum and pink salmon
runs in western Alaska were even more dismal in Chukotka.Hope
survives.
In the early 1990s the Hope Dog Sled Race ran
up the coast from Nome to the village of Wales, where Russian
helicopters transported the teams across the Bering Strait's 60
miles of moving ice to the village of Uelen. From there, the mushers
raced down the Russian coast to Anadyr, the administrative center of
Chukotka. The international race was suspended in 1994 because of
political and economic chaos in Russia, and most Alaskans assumed
the race had just faded away. But when I arrived in Lavrentia last
April I discovered that the Hope Race was one element of early
Chukotka-Alaska relations that has remained active, at least on the
Russian side. This year 27 Native mushers raced 350 kilometers from
Lavrentia to Provideniya and back, cheered on by crowds in the
villages and towns enroute.
The number of dog teams in
Chukotka has exploded as gas, spare parts and money for snowmachines
become scarce. Lessons learned from Alaska racers on breeding,
feeding and equipment have helped the Chukotka mushers improve the
performance of their teams, which they now depend on for survival as
well as competitive sport. All mushers I spoke with are easger to
again match their teams against those of Alaskans.
The
future?
They have a joke in Chukotka that goes, ``How come
America is so poor they only had enough money to buy Alaska and not
Chukotka, too?'' It's too late to correct that oversight, but an
Anadyr newspaper recently reported that Roman Abramovich, a declared
candidate in Chukotka's Dec. 24 election for governor, promises to
turn Chukotka into the second Alaska if he wins. He visited Alaska
twice this fall to meet with Gov. Tony Knowles and numerous
organizations eager to develop a wide range of ties with the Russian
Far East.
Alexander Nazarov, the governor of Chukotka since
1992, has discouraged economic, cultural and humanitarian relations
between Chukotka and Alaska. When I asked why people continue to
vote for the current governor, I received the same answer. ``It
doesn't matter who you vote for. It only matters who counts the
votes.'' High voter turnout is expected this Christmas Eve, with
everyone watching closely.
Several years ago the
Yupik people of Alaska's Saint Lawrence Island brought the needs of
their Chukotkan relatives to the attention of local churches. Since
that time a number of churches and organizations have worked to
provide food, clothing, medical assistance and subsistence equipment
to the Chukotka villages. Alexander, a hunter from New Chaplino,
stretched his arms out wide and asked me tell others, Thank you!
Big, big thank you! In Sireniki, a mother and unpaid seamstress
burst into tears as she explained that the only clothes they had
were gifts from Alaska. Basic items like fishing nets, lures and
skin sewing needles from Alaskan Friends of Chukotka are helping to
keep people alive. Even Abramovich, considered one of Russia's
wealthiest men, has established a personal fund to help with some
immediate food supplies. But the winter remain long and cold and the
needs staggering.
I overheard an Alascom worker on his way
out of Provideniya last spring observe, ``There is no shortage of
misery in this country.'' This remains true, but the fact that
people need each other more than ever for their survival may in some
ways help to strengthen communities. In every village, when people
finished telling me of their hardships, they invariably expressed
their concern that it was even worse in other villages.
I
also observed that people still find joy in the beauty of the tundra
and the sea that lie just beyond their coal-dusted villages. All
were eagerly awaiting summer's green plants and birds when I left. I
was often told, ``Come back in the summer, it is beautiful here
then.''
I'll come back, I thought, because the resiliency,
the humor and the beauty of the people are as moving as the
landscape.
Sue Steinacher is a free-lance writer and past
contributor to Heartland who recently moved from
Nome
|